Salt & Pepper Italian Bistro Pizza

Dawn Noritsky 2 months ago

2 sodas (one was like water- since tank ran out) replaced upon request. 1 medium cheese pizza. Not fully cooked. $22 total. No taste. Only couple in dining room. I would say pass....go to Domino's.

Donna Musser 6 months ago

I placed an order for delivery, lg pizza with onion. The pizza came with a disgusting meat, no onion. The order at Salt and Pepper showed onion, the manager said he made a mistake. He was rude, very rude, said he isn’t perfect. The only way I could get my onion pizza was to go there to get it. If I could have gone there I would not have placed a delivery pizza. Terrible service, very rude manager. Very unprofessional. They totally lost my service.

Doug Williams 7 months ago

We ordered through Grubhub, on Superbowl Sunday, and they had our dinners ready and we're delivered early. The sausage, peppers & onions was rival to my Napolitana Grandmother's and the Garlic Knots will be sure to steer vampires clear of S West End Ave for days... This is the read deal, gang...

C G 8 months ago

This place has the best pizza in the entire city. I’ve been going to the same pizza place for almost 20 years. And I decided to try this one late night. When I tell you, I was so surprised on how delicious this pizza was. They have gained a new customer. I look forward to trying other things. Congratulations to you all for perfecting what people think is easy to do.

Ray Metzger II Edited 6 months ago

This was close to 4 Stars, which for this reviewer is a unicorn. Fast efficient service, was slightly over quoted on time which occasionally will cause cancellations, Guests. Location is in a residential/office community. Inside is clean, unevenly taped laminated signage on the glass case is a pet peeve of mine. Mozzarella Sticks were slightly doughy but had flavor, marinara was enjoyable not complex, simple however there was a quality to it that made slightly above average. The cheese burger sub was the callout here. SEASONED WELL!!! Let me repeat for those in the back & past reviewed shops… SEASONED WELL!!! Homage bread ✅, generous portion (medium), decent mayo check ✅, fresh veggies ✅, solid cheese ✅. Burger was ok, it didn’t take away from the experience. If I was being super picky, my preference is white onions vs red, again this did not take away from the experience. Had the moz been cooked better or any 1 of the opportunities identified above not be present, this would have been a 🌟🌟🌟🌟 review.